- Dugout Seat
- Posts
- 'Golden At-Bat' Rule ⚾
'Golden At-Bat' Rule ⚾
Overstatement or MLB Altering?

Should we be preparing for another big Manfred rule?
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred recently revealed that the "Golden At-Bat" rule had been discussed during owners’ meetings and on the Varsity Podcast, igniting a wave of speculation and debate amongst baseball fans.
The idea behind the "Golden At-Bat" rule is pretty wild. Essentially, it would let a team pick one at-bat in every game where they could send up their best hitter—no matter where they are in the lineup. Your star slugger could get another shot at the plate if you need a game-winning homer.
Manfred has tried to calm fans letting them know that this is “conversation only.” Ideally, you'd like the commissioner of a sport actually to like that sport, but given his uninspiring 10-year commissioner history, I think fans are ready to throw flames. We’re talking about the man who implemented extra innings, shift bans, pitch clocks, and ghost runners now trying to throw in a magic hitter.
Not sure if his stance is pro-baseball or pro “I don’t care as long as the Astros win,” but regardless it doesn’t seem like a majority vote. Even Manfred seems opposed. Check out this video of him knocking the idea in 2015. 👇
"You're wasting my time..." – MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred to @stugotz790 back in 2015 when Stu first presented his idea for the "Magic At-Bat" in audio we just unearthed. Manfred recently said MLB is considering a rule change called....The Golden At-Bat.
WATCH:… x.com/i/web/status/1…
— Dan Le Batard Show with Stugotz (@LeBatardShow)
3:18 PM • Dec 4, 2024
To be clear— we think this is utterly ridiculous. In this article by Bleacher Report, they’ve proposed 3 caveats to the GAB and we’d like to add to it:
Can only be used once in a series
The rule can only be used to solve a game that goes over the 9th inning
If the Golden At Bat is implemented, we have to remove the ghost runner rule
Here’s the deal— baseball is a game, not a show. Unless we want the Savannah Bananas to be the new face of the MLB, Manfred has got to let this “conversation” go.
Are you a fan of the Golden At-Bat? |
Enjoying Dugout Seat? Support us by clicking the link below👇
Looking for unbiased, fact-based news? Join 1440 today.
Upgrade your news intake with 1440! Dive into a daily newsletter trusted by millions for its comprehensive, 5-minute snapshot of the world's happenings. We navigate through over 100 sources to bring you fact-based news on politics, business, and culture—minus the bias and absolutely free.
SPRING TRAINING TICKETS ARE HERE🔥
Reply to this email, and we’ll hook you up with Spring Training tickets! If this is your first time reading, don’t forget to hit subscribe for more updates and deals.